Letter in Support of First Nations Land Claims and Tyendinaga Mohawks


signatories@gmail.com <mailto:signatories@gmail.com> PLEASE INCLUDE YOUR AFFILIATION AS YOU WOULD LIKE IT TO APPEAR IN THE LETTER.


Jim Prentice,

Minister of Indian Affairs and Northern Development and Federal Interlocutor for Metis and Non-Status Indians Parliament Hill: House of Commons Ottawa,

Ontario K1A 0A6

Telephone: (613) 992-4275

Fax: (613) 947-9475

E-Mail: Prentice.J@parl.gc.ca <mailto:Prentice.J@parl.gc.ca>

David Ramsay, Ontario Minister Natural Resources and Aboriginal Affairs 6630

– 99 Wellesley St W, 6th Floor, Whitney Block Toronto, ON M7A 1W3

Tel: 416-314-2301

Fax: 416-314-2216

Email: minister@mnr.gov.on.ca <mailto:minister@mnr.gov.on.ca>

July 13, 2007

We, the undersigned, are writing to urge the Province of Ontario to end its complicity in the theft and plunder of First Nations land. Specifically, we ask that the Province stop provinding licenses for resource extraction from lands currently in the Federal land claims negotiation process.

Recent proposed changes to the Federal Specific Claims land claim process have been proposed and may expedite negotiations on some claims. The large majority however, will not qualify for the “fast track.” While claims languish for years and even decades at Federal negotiating tables, Provincial licenses continue to be issued for the very land and resources that are being talked about.

In 1995, the Mohawks of the Bay of Quinte near Belleville, Ontario filed a specific claim for land known as the Culbertson Land Tract. In 2003, the Federal Government acknowledged that the Culbertson Tract had never been surrendered and was in fact Mohawk Land. It was not until late 2006 that negotiations for the return of these lands to Mohawk use and control began in earnest. Despite acknowledgement by the Federal Government that the Mohawks are the rightful owners of the Culbertson Tract lands, the Ontario Ministry of the Natural Resources continues to issue a provincial license to an Ontario company called Thurlow Aggregates. The license allows Thurlow to operate a quarry and the removal of 100,000 tons of gravel annually – or roughly 300 truckloads a month.

Although the Mohawks have repeatedly attempted to have the quarry license revoked while negotiations are underway, the Province continues to maintain that it has no jurisdiction to consider the fact that the Aggregate is on land currently under Specific Claim negotiations.

Conveniently, the Federal government maintains that it cannot deal with ongoing resource extraction because licensing is a provincial issue.

The positioning of the Feds and Province on the Culbertson Tract Aggregate is emblematic of a deceitful and shameful game of “hot potato” played over First Nations land and resources year after year all over Ontario and indeed the country.

If a homeowner suffered a home break-in and robbery, we would not expect him to allow the rest of his belongings to be removed, while, for the next 10 years or so, the value of those items already stolen were determined. Why then are such scenarios permitted when it comes to the Land Claims process?

Not only does it indicate bad faith in land claims negotiations, it is a needless instigator of conflict and confrontation. When negotiations allow such basic unfairness to continue, it can come as no surprise when First Nations people create physical impediments to halt resource extraction, as the Tyendinaga Mohawks have done through their ongoing occupation of the Culbertson Tract Aggregate.

We implore the Provincial Government to revoke the quarry license on the Culbertson Land Tract and thereby commit to negotiating land claims issues in good faith and to honest governance for all Ontarians.

We also strongly encourage the Federal and Provincial Governments to engage in meaningful dialogue to end the exploitation of First Nation lands and resources. We are aggrieved to say that the status quo appears to be a twenty-first century perpetuation of a dismal history of policy that has done great injury to First Nations people and communities.


Sara Abraham, University of Toronto

Maude Barlow

Angad Bhalla

Anthony Hall, University of Lethbridge

Buzz Hargrove, President, Canadian Auto Workers Union

Naomi Klein

Avi Lewis

Claudette Paul, Office Manager, Roach, Schwartz & Associates

Dr. Sherene Razack, OISE

Judy Rebick, Chair, Gindin Centre for Social Justice, Ryerson University

Alissa Trotz, University of Toronto

Cynthia Wesley-Esquimaux, Assistant Professor in Native Studies, University of Toronto

Dr. Cynthia Wright


signatories@gmail.com <mailto:signatories@gmail.com> PLEASE INCLUDE YOUR AFFILIATION AS YOU WOULD LIKE IT TO APPEAR IN THE LETTER.


Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: